Who should get your money?

John PerdueUnclaimed Property
Feb 23 2016

By John Perdue, West Virginia State Treasurer

Several months ago, it was my privilege to return a $5,000 unclaimed property check to a man from Hinton. Joseph Bigony thanked me. He told me that had it not been for my office’s Unclaimed Property Division, he never would have known he was due this money from his sister’s estate. His sister died almost 16 years ago.

A large insurance company held onto this money for years. It finally reported it to our Unclaimed Property Division after being pressured into a regulatory settlement with various states.

That agreement stemmed from an ongoing battle between states and insurance companies as to whether companies have an obligation to search Social Security’s Death Master File (DMF). Why is this important? A DMF search reveals which policy holders are dead, triggering payment to heirs. Still, insurance companies feel it is their right to hold onto someone else’s money.

I have been in the middle of this fight as your State Treasurer, working to make certain insurance companies relinquish these funds. I took this fight all the way to the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals.

In June 2015, the High Court unanimously ruled that the death of the insured triggers the duty to pay out proceeds. The court also said that insurance companies must make reasonable efforts to determine whether their insureds have died. If they are unable to locate beneficiaries, they must report those proceeds to the State as unclaimed property.

There are 19 other states that took a different route, and passed legislation to ensure that insurance companies make a reasonable effort to pay out claims. Similar legislation is pending in six states. But incredibly, this state’s lawmakers are working to do the exact opposite. The bills are HB4473 and SB599. I would gladly welcome your help in fighting them.

This proposed legislation says insurance companies have NO obligation and NO responsibility to check the DMF or a similar list to find out if the insured has died. I should point out that many insurance companies already conduct a similar search to suspend annuity payments. Companies cut off annuities for their own benefit but refuse to use the same file to pay out policies. I find this deeply disturbing.

People purchase life insurance with the expectation that their families will be taken care of during a most vulnerable time. It is our duty as public servants to protect these widows, children and loved ones and make sure they receive what they are due. It is not our duty to protect special interest groups and out-of-state insurance company executives. 

Joe Bigony said he was glad to finally get the money owed his family. But he added it would have been better to have received it when he dug into his own bank account to bury his sister almost 16 years ago.

 This is about a commitment insurance companies made to people long ago. They vowed they would be there for families during their time of need, at the time of their loved one’s death. We owe it to the people of this state not to pass legislation that undermines this commitment.

Recent Posts
Meet the 2019 SMART5.29K Run/Walk Ambassador Family
3/19/2019 10:00 AM | WVTreasury
When I Grow Up contest kicks off 12th year
1/10/2019 4:00 PM | WVTreasury
Give the gift of an education
11/26/2018 1:04 PM | WVTreasury
Preparing for National Retirement Security Week
10/16/2018 10:00 AM | WVTreasury
Smart Start Awards enter 4th year
9/4/2018 10:00 AM | WVTreasury
A Unique Opportunity to Increase Financial Literacy
8/27/2018 10:00 AM | WVTreasury
SMART529 Myth or Fact
7/17/2018 10:00 AM | WVTreasury
Town employees saving for retirement
6/7/2018 11:27 AM | WVTreasury
Fourth annual SMART5.29K event May 19
4/30/2018 10:36 AM | WVTreasury
The Rules Have Changed!
3/6/2018 11:00 AM | WVTreasury
The Treasury does not collect state taxes. Visit the The West Virginia State Tax Department for assistance.

West Virginia State Treasurer's Office
1900 Kanawha Boulevard
Capitol Complex Building #1, Room E-145
Charleston, West Virginia 25305
304-558-5000 Toll Free: 800-422-7498

Copyright 2019 by West Virginia State Treasurer's Office